Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Barbara Mathews's avatar

I'm so glad to hear (1) that you've been an authentic Marjie Alonso since the 1970s, and (2) that you brook no nonsense about books being individual works of art that cannot be compromised.

I agree totally with you: rip them up, read them in nicely portable chunks, make papier mache from them. Use the covers to make junk journals. But don't set them in your personal library where they educate no one else. It's the intellectual's equivalent of mounted heads of hunted animals.

Expand full comment
Eileen Anderson's avatar

This is great. I get tired of book fetishism.

Years ago I worked for a collection development librarian at a university library. I was the person in charge of the disposition of donated books. It gave me a window into people's behavior, including my own, regarding books. It seems like such a win to people to donate their books to a library. But libraries have curated collections. They don't need someone's old copy of A Million Little Pieces or a whole set of the Darkover novels. So we, like most libraries, took a few into the collection, less than 5%. We threw away the worst stuff and put the stuff in the middle into a book sale. And gave people little charitable contribution letters. and then they would get pissed off when they found out their books went into a sale, even though that was in the letter.

But I do understand the urge of not wanting to *waste* a book. Certainly someone wants it! (I use Bookmooch to get rid of mine.)

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?